Back to Blog
Content Creation

Use Time of Day Data, Not Random Posting Advice

ShortsFireDecember 22, 20250 views
Featured image for Use Time of Day Data, Not Random Posting Advice

Why Generic “Best Time to Post” Advice Fails

You’ve probably seen the graphics:

Those tips can be helpful as a starting point, but they’re guesses that ignore your specific reality:

  • Your audience may live in different time zones
  • Your viewers might have different work, school, or sleep patterns
  • Your content might attract night owls, shift workers, or students
  • Your niche might perform better outside “normal” hours

If you create content for gamers, midnight for your audience might crush. If you create productivity content, early mornings might win. A generic chart can’t tell you that.

ShortsFire creators who grow fastest treat “best time to post” as a data question, not a belief. You already have that data in your analytics. You just need a simple system to read it and test it.

This post will show you how.

Step 1: Define What “Best Time” Means For You

“Best time to post” is vague. You need to decide what you’re actually optimizing for.

For short-form content, there are 3 main options:

  1. Views in the first 1-2 hours
    Good if you care about:

    • Faster feedback on whether a hook is working
    • Early momentum that might help the algorithm

  2. Total views over 24-72 hours
    Good if you care about:

    • Overall reach
    • Longer shelf life for your Shorts/Reels

  3. Quality views
    Good if you care about:

    • Watch time percentage
    • Follows or subscribers gained
    • Clicks to your long-form content, site, or offer

You don’t have to pick only one, but you should clearly prioritize.

Example:

  • A ShortsFire growth-focused creator might say:
    “My primary goal is more followers and subscribers. My secondary goal is good watch time.”

That clarity matters because your “best time” might be different for raw views vs loyal followers. High quality viewers might watch at slightly different hours than casual scrollers.

Step 2: Pull Your Own Time of Day Data

Now you want to see when your audience is actually active and when your content performs best.

On YouTube Shorts

  1. Go to YouTube Studio
  2. Open Analytics
  3. Click the Audience tab
  4. Look for “When your viewers are on YouTube”

You’ll see purple bars for days and times. Darker bars mean more of your viewers are active.

Also:

  • On the Content tab, filter for Shorts only
  • Sort your Shorts by Views and then by Average view duration or View percentage
  • Note the publish time of your top performers

On TikTok

  1. Go to your Profile
  2. Tap the menu (three lines)
  3. Open Creator tools or Analytics
  4. Go to the Followers tab
  5. Scroll to see when your followers are most active by hour and day

For posts:

  • In Content, open top videos
  • Check the publish time
  • Compare with their performance: views, watch time, new followers

On Instagram Reels

  1. Go to your Profile
  2. Tap Insights
  3. Open Total followers
  4. Scroll to Most active times (hours and days)

Then:

  • In Content you shared, filter for Reels
  • Sort by Reach or Plays
  • Check publish times of top Reels

Step 3: Match Audience Activity To Actual Results

Most creators stop at “my audience is active at 6 pm” and think they’re done.

That’s only half the story.

You want to look at two layers of data:

  1. When your audience is most active
  2. When your best-performing content was actually posted

Sometimes they match. Sometimes they don’t.

Create a Simple Time-of-Day Snapshot

Do this by hand or in a basic spreadsheet. For the last 30-60 days:

  1. Take your top 20-30 posts on each platform

  2. Write down:

    • Date and time published (in your local time)
    • Views in first 2 hours (if you tracked them)
    • 24-72 hour total views
    • Watch time percentage or average view duration
    • New followers/subscribers gained from that post (if available)

  3. Bucket them into time ranges such as:

    • Early morning: 5 am - 9 am
    • Late morning: 9 am - 12 pm
    • Afternoon: 12 pm - 4 pm
    • Evening: 4 pm - 9 pm
    • Late night: 9 pm - 2 am

  4. Look for patterns:

    • Which time block holds more of your top posts?
    • Where do you see the best watch time and follow growth?
    • Are there time blocks that rarely produce hits?

You don’t need perfect stats. You just want to see patterns in your own data rather than trusting a generic chart.

Step 4: Pick 2-3 “Core Windows” To Test

Now you’ll turn those observations into a schedule you can actually test.

Choose Your Windows

From your snapshot, pick:

  • 1 primary posting window
    • Example: 6 pm - 8 pm, where most of your top posts live
  • 1 backup window
    • Example: 11 am - 1 pm, which performs second best
  • 1 experimental window
    • Example: Late night, if your niche might fit night owls or international viewers

You can do this per platform, or start with YouTube Shorts and then apply what you learn to TikTok and Reels.

Example Schedule

If you post one Short per day:

  • Mon to Thu
    • Post in your primary window
  • Fri
    • Post in your backup window
  • Sat
    • Post in your experimental window
  • Sun
    • Use the window that historically gives you the best weekend performance

Stick to this for at least 3-4 weeks so you gather enough data.

Step 5: Judge Time Of Day Separately From Content Quality

A huge mistake is blaming time of day for a bad video or crediting time of day for a banger.

You need a simple mental model:

  • Posting time affects:
    • How quickly the algorithm finds the right viewers
    • How strong early engagement looks
  • Content quality affects:
    • Watch time
    • Rewatch rate
    • Shares and follows
    • Long term performance

To keep this straight:

  1. Compare videos with similar quality

    • Similar hook strength
    • Similar topic and thumbnail style (for Reels and Shorts feeds)

  2. See how those similar videos behave at different times of day

    • Did you see better early views when posted in your primary window?
    • Did the same type of video do worse at 9 am vs 7 pm?

If a video is clearly weaker, don’t write off that posting time. Focus on comparing “apples with apples.”

Step 6: Adjust Slowly, Not Randomly

Your goal is a stable posting system, not constant chaos.

Use this simple process every 4-6 weeks:

  1. Review the last month’s content
  2. Sort by your main metric:
    • Views in 24-72 hours
    • Or new followers/subscribers
  3. Look at the time-of-day bucket for your top 10-20 posts
  4. If a new time block shows up often:
    • Move that block into “primary” or “backup” status
    • Downgrade a weaker block to experimental or drop it

Change only one major thing at a time:

  • Don’t overhaul your posting time, your hook style, and your topics all in the same week
  • Otherwise you won’t know which change helped or hurt

Platform-Specific Timing Tips (Based On Data, Not Myths)

These are trends you can compare against your own analytics. They’re not rules.

YouTube Shorts

  • YouTube cares about longer tail performance, not just the first hour
  • Good content can rise later if the viewer fit is strong
  • For many creators:
    • Evenings and weekends show higher total views
    • But weekdays can bring higher quality viewers for educational or work-related content

Use your “When your viewers are on YouTube” chart, but always cross-check it against your top Shorts list.

TikTok

  • TikTok traffic can spike hard in the first few hours
  • The app is more volatile, so timing can matter more for early momentum
  • Check:
    • When your followers are active
    • When your videos got the fastest ramp in views

If you see consistent spikes when posting right before your audience peak, that might be your best window.

Instagram Reels

  • Reels often get distributed across a longer period
  • Your followers’ “Most active times” are a solid starting point
  • Cross-check:
    • When your Reels have the best saves and shares
    • When you gain the most new followers per Reel

Sometimes the “best” time for reach is not the best time for follows. Decide which you care about more.

Practical Action Plan You Can Start This Week

Here’s a simple 7-day plan you can follow with ShortsFire or any posting workflow.

Day 1-2: Pull data

  • Open YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram analytics
  • Write down:
    • When your audience is most active
    • The publish times of your last 20-30 high-performing posts

Day 3: Build your snapshot

  • Group posts into time blocks
  • Mark:
    • Which blocks show up most in your top posts
    • Which blocks rarely produce wins

Day 4: Choose windows

  • Pick:
    • 1 primary window
    • 1 backup window
    • 1 experimental window

Day 5-7: Start the test

  • Post consistently using those windows
  • Track:
    • Views at 24 hours
    • Watch time percentage
    • New followers/subscribers per post

Repeat this for 3-4 weeks, then adjust.

The Real Advantage: You Own Your Timing Strategy

Most creators post when they feel like it or when some chart told them to.
You can do better than that with the data you already have.

Your timing strategy should:

  • Reflect your actual audience, not a generic average
  • Align with your goals: views, watch time, or follower growth
  • Evolve slowly based on clear patterns, not guesses

When you treat time of day like a testable variable, it becomes one more lever you can pull to make your Shorts, TikToks, and Reels perform better.

You already have the analytics. Use them.

content creationshorts strategyanalytics